Technology

Tool case in the test: 10 tool cases in comparison


17. 01. 2020, 06: 16 | by Kilian Scharnagl

content based on the test results from GuteWahl.de

Tools everyone should have

No matter whether for small repairs in the household, the new shelf or the project in the basement: A good tool box is versatile, high quality and neatly organized.

Our partner GuteWahl.de checked in July 2019 ten tool cases with a price of 90 to 240 euros on quality, ergonomics, workmanship and more Criteria. The tool case from Meister was able to convince us with very good workmanship and clever additional tools.

You can read this in this article : First we give you an overview of our recommendations and then discuss them in detail. Below you will find a summary of the test field, further facts about the test procedure, what to look for when buying, tips and tricks about the products as well as answers to the most burning questions.

Tool case test: That are the best tool cases

Top recommendation: Meister tool case

  • Source: Gutewahl.de

    Top recommendation: Meister tool case

    With the solid basic equipment of the master you are well prepared for pretty much all smaller and larger tasks.

Benefits
very good workmanship
clever sorting
practical extras
Disadvantage
small spirit level

Perfectly matched for the casual tradesman, the Tool case from Meister everything your heart desires – neither too much nor too little.

  • Compilation: The tool case from Meister lives up to its name: The case offers solid basic equipment for the workbench in the garage , We particularly liked the key to the heater ventilation. We know from experience that the small key is quickly lost. In this tool case, however, it has its fixed place, so it is indirectly prevented.
  • Sorting: Keeping things tidy is an art and master is one of them, well, master: they are clearly and quickly accessible 46 x 32 x 14 centimeters 121 Tools and parts included ebracht. White drawings of the wrench, pliers and other tools reveal where the individual utensils belong. This way you can also immediately notice if something is missing.
  • Processing: Both the case and the tools themselves are of high quality.
  • Ergonomics: The grip is not only ideal in the hand: socket wrenches and bits are a perfect fit; there is nothing jerky. The only flaw we could find: the spirit level is a little small. There are bonus points for the included LED light.

We particularly liked the fact that the master kept tools in pockets that make removing and tidying up much easier compared to Velcro fasteners. Thanks to the high quality and sensible selection of tools, the master climbs the podium and wins first place. The tool case from Meister is available from Amazon from round 140 Euro.

Price tip: Mannesmann tool case

  • Source: Gutewahl.de

    Price tip: Mannesmann tool case

    We particularly liked it in addition to the price-performance ratio, the Ta The fact that there is space in the case for your own tools.

Benefits
good tool selection
compact
clearly sorted
Space for extra tools
Disadvantage
Case falls too easily
Removal of the tools laborious

You won't get a better one for this price: the tool case from Mannesmann has everything the handyman needs and is also suitable for smaller apartments.

  • Compilation: The selection is definitely enough for smaller jobs and repairs around the house.
  • Sorting: The case itself is made of aluminum and is comparatively small (34 x 45 x 13 cm). So it fits into smaller apartments. Despite the size, the case is well sorted. We found it a shame that the tools were sometimes difficult to remove from the loops. However, it is good and rare that there is space and storage space for additional tools in the lower compartment .
  • Processing: The case is basically nicely processed. If there is no counterweight in the form of heavier tools in the floor, the light case falls over too easily when the sorting aid is folded down in the middle.

  • Ergonomics: The tools are comfortable to hold , but have somewhat sharp edges. However, this is complaining at a high level, in principle we liked the tools very much.

Few disadvantages, but many advantages: The tool case from Mannesmann comes with a purchase price from around 90 Euro on Amazon our price tip.

Professional recommendation: Projahn tool case

  • Source: Gutewahl.de

    Professional recommendation: Projahn tool case

    The projection impresses with professional quality and a selection from almost 150 tools. Therefore, it is also more expensive than other tool cases in the test.

Benefits
excellent tool quality
perfect fit
easily removable tools
Disadvantage
6mm combination spanner missing
high price

Do you call yourself a real home improvement? Then the Projahn is the right suitcase for you. A large selection and good quality justify the reasonably high price.

  • Compilation: Here the project dominates, it is the wet dream of a craftsman. With a total of 149 The selection is huge. The plastic case contains not only a hammer, pliers and wrench, but also a slide gauge, a set of chisels, a saw for metal and a wood saw, spatula, arrows, flashlight and chisel. You can also find large and small ratchets in the projection. There are matching nut sizes 4 to 32 millimeters and various extensions and joints. The combination wrenches are available from eight to 22 millimeters. However, we would also like a key with a size of six millimeters, as this size is necessary for many bicycle repairs.
  • Sorting: In this respect the projection is similar to the master – the white background makes it easy to re-sort used tools.
  • Processing: As you can already guess from the price, the quality of the individual tools of the project is really high. We are also very happy about the fit and accuracy of the socket wrench and bits.
  • Ergonomics: The Handles of the tools feel good. This makes the work much easier.

The universal tool case from Projahn is from round 240 Euro available and every jack of all trades the perfect companion at the workbench, in the garage or wherever work always pending.

Other tool cases in the test

Gedore offers two different tool cases with both 70 as well as 100 parts – even with the larger case we often looked in vain for certain tools. The universal craft case is very expensive and of high quality, but only offers a small number of components.

The has significantly more content Connex occasional case With 116 Divide. It comes from the same manufacturer as our test winner. However, the selection is a little different and we also liked the accommodation less than with the master.

The Tool case from kwb lies in terms of its equipment between the Projahn and the master (129 parts) and the compilation also makes sense – unfortunately, the processing was rather average.

The household tool case from WorkPro is quite cheap, but that doesn't mean that it's bad – the suitcase is just okay. Kraftwerk's case promises a lot, but is also only average.

The tool case from Universal also disappointed with its price-performance ratio.

How much do I have to spend on a good tool case?

A tool case is an investment that you can ideally use for decades. That's why you should pay attention to quality, especially if you work a lot. If you only need to carry out basic repairs at home, we recommend buying a rather small craft case. However, you should pay particular attention to the quality of the individual tools. Depending on how much you work on your own projects at home, a larger and thus more expensive suitcase may also be worthwhile. Well-known and popular brands are usually a little more expensive, but this pays off in the long run.

Die Tool cases in our test field cost between around 90 and 240 Euro. Our test also shows that you have a good suitcase for around 90 Get euros – this is how much our Price tip from Mannesmann .

Tool case in the test: so rated GuteWahl

The trained carpenter Gunnar Brand tested the tool boxes for our partner GuteWahl. The first quality inspection initially consisted of the intensive assessment of the test objects. Brand paid particular attention to the proper sorting of the contents and their compilation.

In the subsequent practical test, he turned screws in wood with the screwdrivers , The lock screw was used to test the ergonomics and accuracy of the socket and wrenches, and the side cutters, combination pliers and hammer were subjected to a load test. A nice side effect: Brand also immediately assessed how easily the tools could be removed, but also how he was able to tidy everything up quickly. The most important test criteria were accuracy of fit, ergonomics, composition and processing.

Author Gunnar Brand testing a key to vent the heater. Gutewahl.de

What are tool cases and how do they work?

A tool case is a container made of plastic or light metal like Aluminum in which you can store tools. The right material often offers both longevity and low weight, as well as protection for the tools. Since the most important function of a tool case is order, you should especially look for systems that focus on it. This happens, for example, through the corresponding compartments or loops for certain tools.

What types of tool cases are there?

Tool cases are available in three different versions, the differences of which we will explain to you here.

  • Bare Tool case:

    If you insist on special or your own tools, we recommend this version. Empty tool cases are also cheaper. If you only need a container for existing tools, it should be a case with at least 36 liters of storage space.
  • Partially equipped tool case:

    An interim solution is a partially equipped tool case. This is already filled with the most common tools, but still offers space for further purchases and special needs.

  • Tool case equipped: An equipped tool case makes sense, if you don't want to fill the case yourself as a beginner. These are often cheaper than buying them individually.

What do I have to pay attention to when buying tool cases?

Before you look around for a tool case, you should think about what you need it for. Someone who only wants to build a shelf or hang a picture from time to time certainly doesn't need a professional set. In addition to equipment, costs and weight, you should still consider the following criteria:

  • Ergonomics: Tool must lie well in the hand. Plastic residues and sharp edges should not be present for safety reasons alone. Tools that are comfortable to hold also prevent blistering. In the best case, the handle prevents you from slipping even with sweaty hands. Ergonomics in the broadest sense can also be related to the weight of the case – if you fiddle with it all day, it shouldn't be too heavy. This could affect your work.

  • Processing: Either Tools as well as the case itself should meet the safety standards. For example, the steel of a wrench or screwdriver must be sufficiently stable so that e r does not bend. The handles should never be able to detach from the tool. In general, the tool should not wear out quickly. Instead of investing more money on the table for the replacement, you should invest more in the first purchase.
  • Fit accuracy: Straight wrenches, screwdrivers and similar tools should fit the materials to be processed as precisely as possible. If this is not the case, you can damage it quickly. Screws in particular noodle quickly. So that power can also be transmitted, everything must fit together perfectly; otherwise the risk of injury increases.

What are the alternatives to the tool case?

There are two alternatives to tool cases: the tool trolley and the workbench.

The tool trolley is basically a tool case on wheels. You pull the trolley on a telescopic pole. Since you don't have to lift the case, the weight of the trolley doesn't matter. That is why they are often made of steel.

You and your tool don't have to be mobile, you can stationary in a Workbench or one Tool cabinet store. Here you should note: Also, the tool must not only be kept safe for the sake of the tool – if you have children, every easily accessible drawer is a potential source of danger.

What tools should be included?

Tool cases are often strongly oriented towards a certain purpose. So is the Suitcase from kwb Particularly suitable for electricians, but most readers should not invest extra here. A certain basic equipment should always be available. This includes the following:

  • Hammer
  • a small selection of pliers (e.g. combination pliers and pipe wrenches)

  • a key set (especially screw and socket wrench)

  • Phillips and flat-head screwdrivers in the usual sizes (PZ 1 and PZ 2)

  • Cutting tools (cutters, side cutters, etc.)

  • Measuring and testing devices (tape measure, spirit level, yardstick, etc.)

  • sawing (possibly Wood and metal)

  • a phase tester

  • a cordless screwdriver

In our test environment there are very extensive craft cases, some of which go far beyond the selection of equipment just described. If you buy a suitcase, you have to decide for yourself what you really need and what you don't; work and repair pretty much everything that arises in the house, we recommend a suitcase with more than 100 Divide.

What is a tool case trolley?

On tool bag trolley is another word for the one described above tool trolley . These are often made of steel and therefore weigh more than the average tool case. In addition, a tool trolley basically looks like a cupboard on wheels with a telescopic handle: the tool and other utensils can be found in drawers.

Tool trolleys are more for ambitious do-it-yourselfers who have no space for a complete workshop but still have more tools as a tool case.

Where can you find good offers for tool cases?

If you are looking for a tool box, you do not necessarily need to make a pilgrimage to the hardware store. Aldi, Real or Lidl also have reasonably satisfactory products. However, these are often very cheap, which is why you cannot necessarily rely on the quality.

If you want to be on the safe side, we recommend the well-known Mekkas for DIY enthusiasts: Obi, Hornbach, Bauhaus , Hellweg and Co. You will also receive excellent advice on site. You should pay attention to well-known brands such as Makita, Mannesmann, Resco or Proxxon.

How do you maintain a tool case?

Tool cases are of course a daily commodity and must be able to withstand a lot without falling apart after a week. Of course, you do not have to expose the tool case to weekly cleaning, but you should at least wipe tools after use with a damp cloth and check for rust if possible. You should be able to get rid of it with a rust remover.

Speaking of rust: Of course, you should dry objects made of aluminum before you put them in the right place return. If you have bought a PVC tool case, you do not have to worry about care and maintenance.

The most important questions about tool cases at a glance

Which tool case is the best?

Our test winner is the Tool case from Meister and could especially benefit from its good workmanship and clever tool selection as well as practical extras. The only disadvantage: the small spirit level.

How much do I have to spend on a good tool case?

Should the tool last a few years, you have to at least 50 to about 100 Euro change owners. Make sure you also pay attention to how many tools it contains – the following applies: quality before quantity.

What Tool should my tool case have?

The classics are a must: Screwdriver, a hammer, one pliers , a saw and Cutter, wrench , one Spirit level and tape and Bit systems should be included. Many tool cases are specific to certain areas of responsibility – so take a close look at the description of the tool case.

What are Manufacturer for tool case?

Well-known manufacturers, by whom one can direct oneself, are for example Makita, Würth, Brüder Mannesman, Resco, Proxxon and of course also Master.

Related Articles

Close