Technology

Music box for children in the test: winner of the Stiftung Warentest


Music and fantasy trips at the push of a button

| by

Music boxes for children: 13 Models passed the test of the Stiftung Warentest. WINZKI / photographer: Michelle Kathrin Weber

The tasks of a cassette player nowadays take over so-called music boxes for children. At the push of a button, pieces of music or stories can be played easily and anywhere on CD, Internet or memory cards. Ideally, these devices should be designed so that children can operate them on their own.

The Stiftung Warentest tested 13 Music boxes and CD players for children in November 2019. Test winner Hörbert von Winzki refers the well-known Toniebox by Boxine to second place. The price range between the music players is relatively large. So you can already use devices from 27 euros. But it is also much more expensive: The test winner Hörbert is also with a price of around 240 Euro the most expensive of the test field.

You can read this in this article: First we present the three best music boxes in the ranking. The detailed test results for the best models follow, as well as the background of how the test was carried out. Then read what you should pay attention to when buying a music box and clarify any important questions you might have about the topic.

Music boxes for children tested: Winner of the Stiftung Warentest

Best music box for children Best CD player for children Alternative music box for children

Product

Winzki Hörbert

Lexibook Avengers

Boxine Toniebox

Overall Rating

“good” (1, 8th)

“satisfactory” (2.8)

“satisfactory” (3.0)

Rank

1 (category music box)

1 (CD player category)

2 (category music box)

Age group

unlimited

unlimited

Small child

Price

round 240 Euro

round 50 Euro

round 80 Euro (device only

Most Popular Shop

To the shop (Amazon) To the shop (Amazon) To the shop (Amazon)

Price comparison

Compare prices

No further prices

Compare prices

Order Music box for children: Winzki Hörbert

  • Source: Photo: Winzki / Amazon

    Best music box for children: Winzki Hörbert

    Rating : “good” (1.8), category: music box for children , scores particularly well with workmanship, durability, security and battery.

Benefits
very good volume
very good workmanship
very good battery
very good security
Disadvantage
sound quality only satisfying
Pollutants only satisfactory
very expensive

The music box Hörbert of the company Winzki is the best device in the test. Its natural wooden body convinces with the idea of ​​sustainability and easy handling. In addition, please like the technical details, such as the preset maximum volume.

  • Features: In comparison to other music boxes Hörbert can score in the overall package. The music player comes with an included memory card that already has stories and songs. It also has its own software that enables parents to transfer data to a microSD card. The design is simple: different contents can be selected using buttons in different colors. Inside, parents have the option of adjusting a separate volume control so that the children's ears are protected.
  • Processing and handling: The music player from Winzki can score with a wooden body from sustainable forestry and brings a piece of nature into the children's room; the processing convinced in the test. Radio plays or pieces of music can be selected using nine colored buttons. The gray buttons below allow fast forward and rewind. Hörbert obtains its energy from batteries that can be removed and replaced individually from the device.

Since the music box is supplied with a memory card already fitted, nothing stands in the way of immediate listening pleasure. Unlike the other tested jukeboxes, Hörbert does not contain a battery, but is powered by four AA batteries. Unfortunately, this is not as sustainable as the manufacturer sells itself. Compared to the Toniebox, the Hörbert scores “very good”. Whole 57 He creates hours. Due to the simple structure, defective parts can be exchanged and replaced yourself. The company itself also offers repairs. The maximum volume is still in the green range and can also be reduced using a volume control inside. For this the price is with round 240 Euro relative expensive.

The test winner of the Stiftung Warentest. Winzki Hörbert scores above all thanks to its reduced volume. Photo: Winzki

Best CD player for children: Lexibook Avengers

  • Source: Photo: Lexibook / Amazon

    Best CD player for children: Lexibook Avengers

    Rating: “satisfactory” (2.8), category: children C D-Player , scores particularly with handling, volume, battery and security

Benefits
good handling
good volume
good battery
good security
Cheap
Disadvantage
Sound quality only sufficient
Processing only satisfactory
Pollutants only satisfactory

The children's music player Lexibook Avengers is a classic compact CD player for children. This most closely resembles the devices with which the new generation of parents grew up themselves.

  • Features: The Lexibook Avengers comes with a CD drive and a built-in radio. You can also connect headphones or an external microphone via an external AUX connection, so that your child can either listen to music in silence or sing along loudly.
  • Handling and processing: Although the processing and the pollutant content in the test are only “satisfactory”, it scores the Avengers in use. In addition, the Stiftung Warentest rates the volume as “good” – the box is largely harmless for children's ears.

The Lexibook Avengers belongs with a price of round 50 Euro to the lower price segment of the test field – but mainly because the Hörbert with its price of around 240 Euro tears up blatantly. For this you get a solid device that can be used by your child after infancy and then used in pre-teens for rock or pop music.

The Lexibook Avengers is a classic compact CD player and therefore ages well with your child. Photo: Lexibook

Alternative music box: Boxine Toniebox

  • Source: Photo: Boxine / Amazon

    Alternative music box: Boxine Toniebox

    Rating: “satisfactory” (3.0), category: music box , scores particularly well with handling, sound quality, processing , Safety and pollutants.

Benefits
good handling
good sound quality
very good workmanship
good security
low pollutant
Disadvantage
too loud for children's ears
battery only satisfying

Because of its popularity and its unusual design, the “Toniebox” from Boxine is now part of many children's rooms. The peculiarity of this box is the handling, since so-called tonies (hearing figures) tell the stories as soon as they are connected to the box. Its functions are very extensive, which is why it is our price tip.

  • Features: The Toniebox comes as a small cube with ears therefore. The ears are also controls at the same time. In order to play pieces of music or radio plays, so-called “tonies” are required, which can be played with different pieces via WLAN. Various contents can be accessed online via the Tonie cloud. Suitable children's headphones provided by the company can be used for undisturbed listening pleasure.
  • Processing and handling: As a compact cube, Stiftung Warentest rates handling as “good” and durability as “very good”. Operation is intuitive. By pulling the ears or tipping the box to the right or left, the volume can be regulated and rewound and rewound. The “Tonies” ensure a successful change and can be exchanged with each other.

The Toniebox needs the Tonie figures to play different contents. These are for 15 euros and therefore relatively expensive if a bit of variety is desired. The advantage, however, is that the figures can be exchanged with other users and can even be borrowed from libraries. The volume of the box is particularly critical when using headphones. However, the company sells special children's headphones that are based on 85 Decibels should be limited. In addition, the from around 80 Euro expensive jukebox set the volume using the Tonie cloud. With more than 140 different content the cloud also offers a nice change.

The Toniebox works very intuitively and is therefore easy to use even for very small children. Photo: Boxine

Practical test on CHIP.de: Toniebox

How much do I have to spend on a good music player?

The question about the price is less important than the question about the functions that the music box should have. If you prefer CDs, you will get from 50 Euro already good devices. The follow-up costs for more CDs should be considered, in order to have a selection of different pieces of music and radio plays. However, CD players also have a longer shelf life and can also be used by older children or teenagers.

Streaming or transferring content to a memory card does not work with these devices. But also for this you get from around 26 Euro already devices that are USB sticks and cloud services with media . Content can also be downloaded via apps, but some of these are linked to a subscription and regularly charge the account.

The Toniebox for round 80 Euro with their Toniefiguren , which are also wonderful for playing. For new figures you always have to Invest euros. Alternatively, you can borrow figures from libraries.

Alternatively, you can also use WiFi speakers or Bluetooth boxes (for testing) look at. Like CD players, these can also be used beyond childhood. However, they are rather something for older children, since they are controlled via a smartphone or tablet. But they are more sustainable and flexible to play on. Music boxes with an SD card slot also work well. These media would then have to be played on by the parents in advance. Bluetooth boxes or boxes with SD cards are already available 26 Euro. In this price category you can choose whether you want to stream or simply transfer content to the memory card – you are already well supplied with a solid device for listening to radio plays and music.

Bluetooth speakers in the test: the best Bluetooth speakers

Music boxes tested: This is how Stiftung Warentest tests them

For the test, the Stiftung Warentest examined 13 Music player for children from three years. The devices either have internal SD or USB memory or are equipped with a CD drive. Some music players also have a microphone. All tested devices were over the period from May to July 2019 purchased from Stiftung Warentest. The sales prices were obtained from retailers.

The experts checked the music boxes for handling, sound, volume, processing and durability, battery and accumulator, electrical safety and pollutants . The actual users checked the handling: children between the ages of three and six years. Experts accompanied the children while they tested the music boxes extensively. The focus was on operation in daily use. Since the products are especially for children, they should be easy to use and the technology should be designed to withstand constant switching back and forth.

The boxes underwent various tests in the Sound and Volume category. The Stiftung Warentest assessed the sound quality based on hearing tests with various genres – such as classical, pop and language. However, this is only really important if you want to use the music player for longer than your childhood. A three-year-old child will only distinguish the difference between high-quality boxes and a compact device in extremely exceptional cases. The volume is therefore more important: Everything about 85 Decibels become critical for children's ears.

Toniebox: From this age the toy is suitable

What is a music box and how does it work?

The music boxes and music players in the test were mainly designed for children from the age of three, but depending on the model, they can be used up to adulthood. The possibilities are almost endless, because streaming services and memory cards mean that even adult users can listen to audio books or music about them. Only the designs designed for children could then disturb the eye.

The basic idea is to hear stories about devices that are both functional and simple and that differ from small ones Have children's hands operated. They should be easy to use.

The boxes are supplied with various contents either via memory cards, listening figures or USB sticks, sometimes also via WLAN and streaming. Some music players also work very traditionally with a CD or even a cassette and have a built-in radio. Some music players also have microphones and can then be used for karaoke singing.

MP3 players for children: the best music players

What types of music boxes are there?

In the case of jukeboxes and music players, we mainly differentiate according to the medium. You can choose a device with a radio, CD or cassette drive in the classic way, or you can reach for more modern models. The latter store content on memory cards and USB sticks or obtain content via Bluetooth or WLAN from apps, streaming services or the cloud. A model, the Toniebox, gets its contents from colorful figures that only work when connected to the music box.

In addition to the medium, you can also pay attention to the accessories. Some boxes are also equipped with a microphone and a karaoke function and allow you to sing along or record vocals.

What should I look out for when buying a music box?

If you want to buy a music box for your children, you should first consider how and how long you want to use the device. You can consider various criteria.

  • storage medium

    How flexible you record on the jukebox depends on the media. This is done either via CDs, cassettes, SD cards, hearing aids, USB sticks or cloud storage. With memory cards and USB sticks, you can determine which and how much content is available to your children. However, the memory is limited. CDs, cassettes and audio figurines will eventually accumulate larger amounts if you want to offer your child a certain range of listening options – unless you lend them. In addition to the purchase, you can also borrow many radio plays and pieces of music from libraries or your child swaps with other children.
  • Handling

    Depending on the age of your child, handling also plays a role. The music boxes can be operated in different ways. Some have colorful buttons that are assigned different functions. Others, on the other hand, work intuitively: this means that devices e.g. B. can be controlled by touching certain elements or by tilting and moving. As a rule, children quickly learn which functions are triggered and how.
  • Battery pack

    In principle we recommend rather a device that can be charged using a battery. With a battery you are flexible and can take the device anywhere and listen to stories or music anywhere. In addition, batteries can be charged, while many batteries cannot. This is bad for the environment and your wallet. If your box has a mains connection, the question does not arise. Then you sacrifice mobility.
  • Processing

    In children's rooms the processing of the music box is of greater importance , because it has to endure a lot. In everyday use, buttons and buttons should be firmly integrated in the device – these are potential small parts that can be swallowed. Check in advance what impression the device makes and whether it can withstand one or more falls. There are big differences in processing when it comes to the materials. There are music players covered with fabric, which are made of wood and many are made of plastic. The Stiftung Warentest tests all materials for harmful substances. With wooden music boxes, you should make sure that it comes from sustainable forestry. Check in advance whether the devices have sharp edges that could possibly lead to injuries.
  • Volume

    It shouldn't be too loud for children's ears and also for your nerves. With some of the tested music boxes, it is possible to adjust the volume inside the device. This is how you limit the maximum volume that your child can set. In addition, some music boxes offer the function of adjusting the volume via the cloud or the device's own firmware. The Stiftung Warentest also assessed the volume of the devices, according to which you can select a device with an adequate volume. Especially the use of headphones should be used with caution, these are often too loud. A Musixbox provider sells extra headphones with volume limitation that are suitable for children.

Toniebox: The 3 best alternatives for children

What are the alternatives to children's music boxes?

The classic CD players, some of which are equipped with a cassette deck, continue to function as an alternative to the modern music boxes. The most famous radio plays and pieces of music can then be purchased on CDs or cassettes. Libraries also often lend CDs, so that the costs for new purchases are kept within limits.

The special feature of classic music players is an additional microphone on selected models. This allows children to experiment and sing to pieces of music. If you want to stream your music or radio plays and want to access a wide range of content, you should consider whether a cheaper Bluetooth box would be a sensible purchase. In addition, the small devices can be transported flexibly and do not take up much space in your luggage. Many devices are also relatively resistant to falls and can get dirty. It should be considered in advance whether you or your children would rather listen to finished radio plays or your own recordings.

Toniebox: Security and data protection – all information

What accessories are there for music boxes?

The accessories vary depending on the jukebox and provider. Some devices have a headphone jack and can be used with both standard and branded headphones.

Most of the music boxes have a rechargeable battery and batteries that work with them the respective device and matching charging stations are offered. Many providers also sell their device with a storage medium that is either already recorded or can be subsequently provided with content.

Should my music box have rechargeable batteries or batteries?

Depending on what you use the jukebox for and when you use it, you should consider whether you should choose a device with a battery or a battery. A battery can be charged at any time when there is an outlet nearby. On the other hand, you either already have batteries at home or you can buy them if you don't have them on the go or while traveling. A battery may turn out to be cheaper and more sustainable in the long run, because you can recharge it again and again and not have to replace it like batteries.

Should the speaker be mono or stereo?

Good speakers often allow a rich sound without being stereo. Another decisive factor is the built-in bass, which gives the sound more space. If you use the jukebox primarily for listening to radio plays or audio books, then a speaker with mono quality is sufficient. For a use that is more aimed at listening to pieces of music, we advise you to use devices with stereo as they allow a more extensive sound experience. However, if you want to use the box mainly in childhood, the sound is secondary to fun and intuitive operation. Of course, the box should sound decent, but a three-year-old child usually hears no difference between hi-fi sound and a compact box. Incidentally, this also applies to some adults.

Does my box need a volume limit?

The volume is therefore more important than the sound quality: The Stiftung Warentest evaluates devices without throttled volume as soon as they exceed the recommended volume level and thus become a danger to your hearing. Children tend to enjoy the full volume and do not notice that the level is too high for their ears. In many boxes, however, the effect only occurs when used with headphones. Some devices can either be retrofitted internally or their volume can be limited using the software. Your children will only hear the maximum volume that you have set previously.

The most important questions about music boxes for children at a glance

Which is the best music box for children?

The best The music box for children is the Winzki Hörbert with the rating “good” (1.8). The device is characterized above all by good operation, and very good volume, processing and safety aspects. The compact CD player Lexibook Avengers took second place with the rating “satisfactory” (2.8). The popular Toniebox only achieved 3rd place in the test by the Stiftung Warentest (“satisfied”, 3.0).

Children's music box: How much should I spend?

The devices from the test field range between around 27 and 240 Euro. The best box is also the most expensive. You get solid music boxes for around 50 Euro.

How important is the sound in a box for children ?

You don't have to make high demands on the sound if you only want to use the box in childhood – unless your offspring is Mozart's rebirth. The sound should sound decent, but you do not need to have any HiFi requirements.

When is a music box too loud for children?

A music box should the critical limit of 85 Never exceed decibels, better is, it is quieter. Some devices are throttled by default, others can be limited in volume later. Children have no hearing for something that is too loud and therefore like to level up to the maximum volume. Especially with headphones this can be dangerous for your hearing.

Related Articles

Close